I think your conclusion is correct, and your napkin arithmetic is illustrative, but it's worth* noting it assumes total lack of correlation between preferences, whereas your diagram represents a scenario I suspect to be more representative of reality, where certain preferences correlate while others anticorrelate, so the actual difficulty of finding a house that meets all preferences in a scenario where each person only likes 1/5 houses on the market would vary wildly.
*Ok, ok. Maybe it's not. Your pedantic mileage may vary.
I almost did my grad thesis in Democratic Theory on intentional communities, it's so fascinating. Thanks for sharing your perspective and experience.
A community I've spent lot of time with started in the 70s with a couple buying the land, and inviting friends to buy in. They adopted consensus democracy, and everyone loved/hated it. Endless monthly meetings with little getting done, because one guy in the group was inclined to kill every new idea. Still the founders stayed devoted to consensus out of principle and the community is basically happy but with a simmering annoyance. These are some of the smartest people I've ever known, btw. A clause to address the One Guy Situation would really help, though.
In contrast, I knew another commune that did majority rule, but with a spiritual (Buddhist-inspired new age) commitment as a point of cohesion. My friends in it claimed to be happier, things got done, but the compulsion to accept anything resembling dogma sounds icky to me and is historically fraught.
I can't name my source, but I once read in a scholarly book on piracy that, in the very active age of European piracy a few hundred years ago, many pirate and buccaneer (pirates with a land base) communities were conditional consensus democracies: in day to day life they used consensus, but when planning an attack, (or during emergencies I imagine,) they would draw straws and appoint a temporary leader to be able to make quick, critical decisions. I find that model compelling.
A small-scale hierarchy based on who has the money is perhaps an interim solution in the currently unstable stage of the death of capitalism, and it sounds like it's working for you, but it looks dangerously like feudalism. I hope you're keeping in mind that even the smallest amount of financial power brings with it a blindness of privilege that even the most well-intentioned, intelligent people can fall into. A privilege-checking mechanism may be helpful, if you don't have one already. Surrendering power is one of the hardest things a homo sapiens can attempt to do. I think our muscles of freedom, trust, and authenticity are atrophied after thousands of years of power imbalance. Wishing you success and hoping your community can find some truths on our road to freedom!
“ I hope you're keeping in mind that even the smallest amount of financial power brings with it a blindness of privilege that even the most well-intentioned, intelligent people can fall into.”
Fascinating. No idea what coliving is or have any particular interest in pursuing it (who knows, maybe I will someday?), but I enjoyed this peek into this other world, and the social logistics behind it. Might offer me useful insights into other kinds of community building in the future.
“Disagree but commit” to supporting a decision is probably the most important life skill that you can learn. You aren’t going to get every preference you want in life and learning to live with the contradictions that brings is often where the work is. It’s also OK to walk away if you can’t commit to supporting a decision. Choosing these moments carefully is another life skill worth learning.
That said once a decision is made there is an onus on the decision makers to facilitate the repair of any schisms in the group and level things out so that any perceived power imbalances are temporary.
100% "The group that succeeded had one or two people willing to decide on behalf of the group. The four that failed tried to reach consensus within the group."
I see this so much. I get so frustrated with plans and adventures waiting on unanimous consensus.
And as a facilitator I know that most of the time people don't think about their actual decision-making process but it's super helpful to not just clarify what decision you (the group) are trying to make but to also clarify the decision-making process.
I’ve been trying (and failing) to communicate this to a friend trying to organize a big event — she can’t commit to a date, place, or budget, because for any given set of parameters one of her 40-ish guests says it would be difficult to attend. Just! Pick! Something! And everyone who wants to do it will try to make it work, some of the invited guests might not even want to attend anyway, and it’s unfortunate if there are people who want to go but still can’t, but they wouldn’t have been able to attend an indefinitely-postponed thing anyway and everyone’s unhappy with an outcome where we all saved up vacation money and PTO for something that never happens.
I definitely like many of the points you've raised I for sure have been in group situations where it feels like no one wants to be the decision maker lol
But I wonder whether when comes to finding a home if making the distinction between wants and needs are useful?
As a disabled person I can walk in a space and know whether it will work or not for me
For my other friends this isn't true, many of them might overlook something that is a deal-breaker for me, not because their ignorant they just don't live in my body
If you have one or two decision makers how do you get everyone's essential needs met in a space?
At this point, in this world, in our generation, that sounds like spoiled brat math. How blinded by privilege must one be to insist on a whim at the risk of the whole project? Collective longevity requires an individual commitment to community that supersedes certain personal druthers.
Tour de force. It’s the same on a fishing boat . Always has been the case.
This is called do-ocracy!
https://communitywiki.org/wiki/DoOcracy
Sing it from the rooftop
I think your conclusion is correct, and your napkin arithmetic is illustrative, but it's worth* noting it assumes total lack of correlation between preferences, whereas your diagram represents a scenario I suspect to be more representative of reality, where certain preferences correlate while others anticorrelate, so the actual difficulty of finding a house that meets all preferences in a scenario where each person only likes 1/5 houses on the market would vary wildly.
*Ok, ok. Maybe it's not. Your pedantic mileage may vary.
you are correct, it's not as dire as i made it seem.
Great post! I think being overly consensus-driven kills a lot of projects.
I almost did my grad thesis in Democratic Theory on intentional communities, it's so fascinating. Thanks for sharing your perspective and experience.
A community I've spent lot of time with started in the 70s with a couple buying the land, and inviting friends to buy in. They adopted consensus democracy, and everyone loved/hated it. Endless monthly meetings with little getting done, because one guy in the group was inclined to kill every new idea. Still the founders stayed devoted to consensus out of principle and the community is basically happy but with a simmering annoyance. These are some of the smartest people I've ever known, btw. A clause to address the One Guy Situation would really help, though.
In contrast, I knew another commune that did majority rule, but with a spiritual (Buddhist-inspired new age) commitment as a point of cohesion. My friends in it claimed to be happier, things got done, but the compulsion to accept anything resembling dogma sounds icky to me and is historically fraught.
I can't name my source, but I once read in a scholarly book on piracy that, in the very active age of European piracy a few hundred years ago, many pirate and buccaneer (pirates with a land base) communities were conditional consensus democracies: in day to day life they used consensus, but when planning an attack, (or during emergencies I imagine,) they would draw straws and appoint a temporary leader to be able to make quick, critical decisions. I find that model compelling.
A small-scale hierarchy based on who has the money is perhaps an interim solution in the currently unstable stage of the death of capitalism, and it sounds like it's working for you, but it looks dangerously like feudalism. I hope you're keeping in mind that even the smallest amount of financial power brings with it a blindness of privilege that even the most well-intentioned, intelligent people can fall into. A privilege-checking mechanism may be helpful, if you don't have one already. Surrendering power is one of the hardest things a homo sapiens can attempt to do. I think our muscles of freedom, trust, and authenticity are atrophied after thousands of years of power imbalance. Wishing you success and hoping your community can find some truths on our road to freedom!
“ I hope you're keeping in mind that even the smallest amount of financial power brings with it a blindness of privilege that even the most well-intentioned, intelligent people can fall into.”
Excellent point!
Good King theory in action, writ small
I'l always remember you saying: This is how everything noteworthy in the world ever gets done!
Yessss! Love this!
Fascinating. No idea what coliving is or have any particular interest in pursuing it (who knows, maybe I will someday?), but I enjoyed this peek into this other world, and the social logistics behind it. Might offer me useful insights into other kinds of community building in the future.
Great article. 💯agree with everything.
“Disagree but commit” to supporting a decision is probably the most important life skill that you can learn. You aren’t going to get every preference you want in life and learning to live with the contradictions that brings is often where the work is. It’s also OK to walk away if you can’t commit to supporting a decision. Choosing these moments carefully is another life skill worth learning.
That said once a decision is made there is an onus on the decision makers to facilitate the repair of any schisms in the group and level things out so that any perceived power imbalances are temporary.
great comment re: life skills.
100% "The group that succeeded had one or two people willing to decide on behalf of the group. The four that failed tried to reach consensus within the group."
I see this so much. I get so frustrated with plans and adventures waiting on unanimous consensus.
And as a facilitator I know that most of the time people don't think about their actual decision-making process but it's super helpful to not just clarify what decision you (the group) are trying to make but to also clarify the decision-making process.
per usual, this was such a needed, helpful, perfectly written piece. Thank you so much for sharing the wisdom of your experience with us!
Yes!!!!!! This!!!
I’ve been trying (and failing) to communicate this to a friend trying to organize a big event — she can’t commit to a date, place, or budget, because for any given set of parameters one of her 40-ish guests says it would be difficult to attend. Just! Pick! Something! And everyone who wants to do it will try to make it work, some of the invited guests might not even want to attend anyway, and it’s unfortunate if there are people who want to go but still can’t, but they wouldn’t have been able to attend an indefinitely-postponed thing anyway and everyone’s unhappy with an outcome where we all saved up vacation money and PTO for something that never happens.
Sounds like a nightmare !
Needs an intervention, I think!
I definitely like many of the points you've raised I for sure have been in group situations where it feels like no one wants to be the decision maker lol
But I wonder whether when comes to finding a home if making the distinction between wants and needs are useful?
As a disabled person I can walk in a space and know whether it will work or not for me
For my other friends this isn't true, many of them might overlook something that is a deal-breaker for me, not because their ignorant they just don't live in my body
If you have one or two decision makers how do you get everyone's essential needs met in a space?
At this point, in this world, in our generation, that sounds like spoiled brat math. How blinded by privilege must one be to insist on a whim at the risk of the whole project? Collective longevity requires an individual commitment to community that supersedes certain personal druthers.